A sceptic of the UFO field, and a Skeptical Inquirer columnist. Robert Sheaffer returns again and again to the debate that follows a sighting. For Jimmy Carter's 1969 sighting in Leary, Georgia, he found the Lions Club records that fixed the date at January 6, 1969. His answer was Venus. He argued that shadows in the McMinnville photographs meant they were taken in the morning, and Hartmann was persuaded. He favoured Jupiter over Tehran in 1976. After Steve Pierce's 2026 post about the Travis Walton case, he named the tower as the Gentry fire lookout on Rim Road.
Stories19
Skeptic who argued the photos were taken in the morning
Skeptic who criticised proponents' use of the report
Sceptic who dated the sighting from Lions Club records and argued for Venus
Skeptic who promoted the Gentry Tower theory
CSICOP UFO subcommittee member
Skeptic who called the case busted on Bad UFOs and in the Skeptical Inquirer
Skeptical Inquirer columnist who covered the misattributed footage
Sceptic who argued the object was a flying insect
Skeptic whose Bad UFOs blog identified the Motion Tile editing
Skeptic author of the Bad UFOs blog
Sceptic who published the first placard reading
