Documents / Report

Robertson Panel Report

The Black Vault · 1953 · 29 pages · text from the file's own layer

This declassified CIA document, released through The Black Vault, reports on the meetings of the Scientific Advisory Panel on Unidentified Flying Objects, which the Office of Scientific Intelligence convened on January 14 to 18, 1953. It includes a history of the sessions and the panel's informal comments, and it appends the formal report signed by H. P. Robertson and others. The panel found no evidence of a direct threat to national security. It recommended stripping UFOs of their special status and starting a public education program.

  • p. 3 …Origin Tremonton, Utah, Sighting Potential Related Dangers Geographic Locations of Unexplained Sightings Instrumentation to Obtain Data…
  • p. 5 …In cooperation 1vi th the Air Technical Intelligence Center, case histories of reported sightings and related…
  • p. 6 …For example, case histories involving radar or radar and visual 25X1A sightings were selected for while…
  • p. 7 …instrumentation watches of patrol cameras searching for sightings of U.F.O.'s. At 1615 Brig…
  • p. 10 …Among the case histories of significant sightings discussed in detail "ivere the follmving: Bellefontaine, Ohio (1…
  • p. 11 …objects sighted• Instances of nFoo Fighters 11 were cited• These were unexplained phenomena sighted by aircraft…
  • p. 12 …It was interesting that in at least two cases reviewed that the object sighted was categorized…
  • p. 13 …Hhat they did not find vras any evidence that related the objects sighted to space travelers…
  • p. 14 …However, the Panel could not accept any of the cases sighted by him because they were…
  • p. 15 …representatives that the objects sighted were not birds, balloons or aircraft, were nnot reflections because there…
  • p. 16 …There was no valid reason for the attempt to relate theobjects in the Tremonton sighting to…
  • p. 17 …The Panel believed strongly that the data available on this sighting was sufficient for positive identification…
  • p. 18 …Page noted that more competent screening or filtering of reported sightings at or near the source…
  • p. 19 …On the other hand, there had been no sightings in the vicinity of sensitive related AE…
  • p. 20 …exposure in order to photograph an alleged sighting in a different part of the sky; This…
  • p. 27 …mc;~EfkSE IN NU1".il3F.R OF SIGHTINGS The consensus of the Panel Has, based upon…
'0. Approved For Re.se 2001/08/07: CIA-RDP81R00560R.00030027-0
k. Hand "jitter 11 frequencies (obtainable from early part of
Tremonton film) were not removed from the plots of the
"single pass plots" at the end of the film.
The Panel believed strongly that the data available on this
sighting was sufficient for positive identification if further data
is obtained by photographing polyethylane "pillow" balloons released
near the site under similar weather conditions, checking bird flight
and relfection characteristics with competent ornithologists and
calculating apparent "G" fo\-ces acting upon objects from their apparent
tracks. It \vas concluded that the results of such tests would prob-
ably lead to creditable explanations of value in an educational or
training program. However, the Panel noted that the cost in technical
manpovrer effort required to follm·r up and explain every one of the
thousand or more reports received through channels each year (1 1 900 in
1952) could not be justified. It was felt that there ~<rill allvays be
sightsings, for -.;.;hich complete data is lacking, that can only be
explained with disproportionate effort and with a long time delay, if
at all. The long delay in explaining a sighting tends to eliminate
any intelligence value. The educational or training program should
have as a major purpose the elimination of popular feeling that every
sighting, no matter how poor the data, must be explained in detail•
Attention should be directed to the requirement among scientists that
a new phenomena, to be accepted, must be completely and convincingly
docun1ented• In other words, the burden of proof is on the sig~r,
not the explainer.
~~~~"!''--~-llwi~.-i'Ji""e';-:-.n:lr"-E' -~.r
~~;~~!ton
Approved For Release 2001/08/07 :t~A-RDP81R00560R000100030027-0

Cases discussed

About this file

Report, cited by the archive. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 29 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.