Documents / Report

Robertson Panel Report

The Black Vault · 1953 · 29 pages · text from the file's own layer

This declassified CIA document, released through The Black Vault, reports on the meetings of the Scientific Advisory Panel on Unidentified Flying Objects, which the Office of Scientific Intelligence convened on January 14 to 18, 1953. It includes a history of the sessions and the panel's informal comments, and it appends the formal report signed by H. P. Robertson and others. The panel found no evidence of a direct threat to national security. It recommended stripping UFOs of their special status and starting a public education program.

  • p. 6 …the results of their analyses of the films mentioned above. This analysis evolved considerable discussion as…
  • p. 7 …A number of case histories were dis- cussed in detail and a motion picture film of…
  • p. 14 …The Panel studied these films, the case history, ATIC's interpretation, and received a briefing by…
  • p. 15 …graph plots of individual frames of the film, show- ing apparent and relative motion of objects…
  • p. 16 …h• .Analysis of light intensity of objects made from duplicate rather than original film• The original…
  • p. 17 …Hand "jitter 11 frequencies (obtainable from early part of Tremonton film) were not removed from the…
  • p. 19 …24-hour instrumentation watch (two frames of film showing nothing distinguishable) J a widespread program of…
  • p. 24 …tvhich ma0e \'Jorlci :Jar II trc.:dninp: films (motion picture anci slide strips) Nas also sue…
  • p. 26 …1vriters and a subcontractor to produce traming films vrould be necessary in addition. The Panel considered…
Approved For Re.e 2001/08/07: CIA-RDP81R00560Roe00030027-0
,•}_:· - . "' ·-,'. ..
d• Objects in the Great Falls case vrere believed to have
probably been aircraft, and the bright lights such reflections•
e. There was no valid reason for the attempt to relate theobjects
in the Tremonton sighting to those in the Great Falls sight-
ing. This may have been due to misunderstanding in their
directive. The objects in the Great Falls sighting are
strongly suspected of being reflections of aircraft kno'vn to
have been in the area.
f• The intensity change in the Trementon lights was too great
for acceptance of the P.I.L. hypothesis that the apparent
motion and changing intensity of the lights indicated eA~remely
high speed in small orbital paths.
g. Apparent lack of guidance of investigators by those familiar
with U.F.O• reports and explanations.
h• .Analysis of light intensity of objects made from duplicate
rather than original film• The original film was noted to
have a much lighter background (affecting relative brightness
of object) and the objects appeared much less bright.
i. Method of obtaining data of light intensity appeared faulty
because of unsuitability of equipment and questionable
assumptions in making averages of readings.
j. No data had been obtained on the sensitivity of Kodachrome
film to light of various intensities using the sarae camera
type at the same lens openings.
-13-
Approved For Release 2001/08/07: CIA-RDP81R00560R000100030027-0

Cases discussed

About this file

Report, cited by the archive. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 29 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.