Documents / Document

MOD file DEFE 24/2032/1

The Black Vault · 492 pages · text from the file's own layer

This Ministry of Defence file, released through The National Archives and published by The Black Vault, holds the MOD's 2002 handling of Dr David Clarke's requests for UFO documents under the Code of Practice on Access to Government Information. It includes the MOD's 9 December 2002 reply, which covered reports from 1976, 1980, 1993 and 1996 and charged £260. It also contains internal emails and file requisitions, plus Foreign Office and United Nations papers from 1978 on Grenada's proposal for UFO research.

  • p. 39 …the of Defence, TvL Robert GaHev, W::'l.s int.::r- ufonauts d~c1dcd. to make…
  • p. 42 …Cor,1mander Even if one accepts that there may be life Robert McLaughiin, United States Navy…
  • p. 55 …think th:.;t the French Iindeed, incredulous, of what the noble Minister of Defence, ~L Robert…
  • p. 65 …my ancestor although he is dead--called Robert Boyle who founded a ·society called the Royal…
  • p. 69 …the then French Minister of Defence, M. Robert Galley gave in 1974 on the subject of…
  • p. 72 …62·9 63·2 .,I Lord GORONWY-ROBERTS: The Government's initiatives on resolutions on arms…
  • p. 95 …Inter radio on 21 February 1974 Nonsieur Robert Galley, then French Ninister of Defence, stated that…
  • p. 98 …Whether they are aware that Monsieur Robert Galley, the then French Minister of Defence, in his…
  • p. 99 …Inter radio on 21st February 1974 Monsieur Robert Galley then French Minister of Defen~e, stated…
  • p. 101 …2h:t Fcbr;Jar; 1974 Monsie-:.1:: Robert Galley. th.;n French. M!n!sier vf…
  • p. 107 …the then French Minister of Defence M•. Robert Galley about unidentified flying objects by M. Jean…
  • p. 108 …The French authorities have now replied, and I enclcse the full text of~ Robert Galley's…
  • p. 109 I ,; I .... ~ • ...... .."' ~ , 'ITEl<VI~ W!'l!H M ROBERT GAtk'"'Y: MINIST~ FOR THE AR}1ED…
  • p. 113 …M Robert Galley Actually the Minister responsible for National Defence, that is, a man who knows…
  • p. 114 …M Robert Galley: "!t is true that there are things which are not understood and which…
  • p. 127 …Lord GORO Y-ROBERTS: The two protocols "" re opened for signature on 12th Dec nber 1977…
  • p. 128 …French Minister of Defence I I M. Robert Galley about unidentified flying objects by M. Jean…
  • p. 135 …then French liftnister o:f Defence, Monsieur Robert Galley, was inter- viewed by Jean-Claude Bourret…
  • p. 137 …contains an oocurate translation of r.r Robert Galley's broadcast in 1974. It also introduces…
  • p. 138 …the then French Minister of Defence, Monsieur Robert Galley, was interviewed by Jean-Claude Bourret about…
  • p. 141 …Inter radio on 21 February f974 Nonsieur Robert Galley, then French ~linister of Defence, stated that…
  • p. 144 …Inter radto on 21st February 1974 Monsieur Robert Galley then French Minister of Defen~e, stated…
  • p. 147 …Whether they are aware that Mon~ieur Robert Galley, the then French Minister of Defence, in…
  • p. 153 …the then French Minister of Defence M•. Robert Galley about unidentified flying objects by M. Jean…
  • p. 154 …the then French Minister of Defence M. Robert Galley about unidentified flying objects by M. Jean…
  • p. 155 …French Minister of Defence i I M. Robert Galley about unidentified flying objects by M. Jean…
  • p. 157 …The French authorities have now replied, a.nd I enclcse the full text of M Robert…
  • p. 162 …M Robert Galley Actually the Minister responsible for National Defence, that is, a man who knows…
  • p. 163 …M Robert Galley: "!t is true that there are things which are not understood and which…
  • p. 181 …French lJti.nister o~ Defence, Mons;eur Robert Galley, was inter- viewed by Jean-Claude Bourret…
  • p. 183 …an OOC\1-rate translation of M Robert Galley's broadcast in 1974. It a~so…
  • p. 184 …the then French Minister of Defence, Monsieur Robert Galley, was interviewed by Jean-Claude Bourret about…
. "','
1451 Television [ 1 DECEMBER 1977 ] and Radio
though of course if the BBC wish to
approach us on this matter sometime
next year we will be perfectly prepared
to listen to what they have to say.
I will, after what has arguably already
been an overlong speech, sum up.
I would repeat that we are glad to have
had this opportunity-! speak for myself
and, I am sure, for all who have partici-
pated in the debate-to pay tribute to the
valuable work which broadcasters un-
doubtedly play in our society. When I
was recently in the United States I was
struck by the very high esteem with which
programmes from this country were
regarded. These programmes, both from
the BBC and Independent Television, are
finding their way on to the networks and
public broadcasting stations in the United
States. Both the BBC and Independent
Television have offices in the United
States selling British programmes and in
1976 the total volume of overseas sales for
the BBC and IBA was over £18 million,
and despite the undoubted fact that a
substantial amount of foreign material is
shown on British television, we still have a
quite significant surplus on our balance of
payments as far as television is concerned,
which is a quite remarkable tribute to both
the BBC and Independent Television.
In the light of what my noble friend
Lord Vaizey said, I shall . avoid the
temptation to say we have the best tele-
vision in the world. My Swedish is
extremely poor, my German is non-existent
and I am a little rusty even in my Nor-
wegian, so I would certainly not make that
claim. Nevertheless, choosingrathermore
neutral language, I would say that our
programmes stand comparison with those
made anywhere else in the world. That is
not to say that we should be pleased with
everything that is produced. To be blunt,
that would be an absurdly complacent
view. Inevitably, there will be cases
from time to time where it is believed that
there have been lapses in taste and
sometimes in sensitivity, but it is for the
broadcasting authorities, not the Govern-
ment, to deal with those. A few such
alleged lapses have been mentioned this
afternoon and we have had them more than
touched on in the Press in recent months.
Nevertheless, we recognise how essential
is the function that the BBC and the
Independent Broadcasting Authority
perform at relatively modest cost to the
community.
There are many general benefits avaiiihle
to all listeners and viewl?r~, a point men-
tioned by many noble Lorqs in the debate.
Apart from the dissemination of news and
information, the encouragement of the
arts and the promotion of education in all
its forms, there are, -as the· noble Lord,
Lord Winstanley, said, the special and
particUlar benefits conferred on the aged,
the infirm and the lonely, for whom ·life
.without the· broadcasting services would
indeed be a miserable existence. In the
Government's view, no formal inquiry is
needed to ensure that proper recognition
is given to the valuable work done by our
broadcasters. Nevertheless, this short de-
bate has at least enabled some of the more
positive achievements of the industry to
secure wider recognition.
Lord FERRIER: My Lords, before the
noble Lord sits down, I should like to
point out that I was looking forward to
hearing the Government's view on my
point about the broadcasting of infor-
mation about Parliament.
Lord HARRIS of GREENWICH: My
Lords, despite what has been, as I have
already indicated, an overlong speech,
it has been impossible to deal with every
point raised, but certainly what the noble
Lord refers to is an important matter, and
I will ensure that it is taken into account
during our discussion of the Annan
Report.
WRITTEN ANSWERS
CUSTOMS AND IMMIGRATION:
HEATHROW AIRPORT
Lord TREFGARNE asked Her
Majesty's Government:
How many Customs and Immigration
officials are presently employed at
Heathrow Airport and how many will
be needed to man the new General
Aviation Terminal there.
The PARLIAMENTARY UNDER-
SECRETARY of STATE. DEPART-
MENT of the ENVIRONMENT (Baroness
Birk): The numbers of Customs officers
and Immigration Service staff employed
at the Heathrow Airport passenger ter-
minals on 31st October 1977 were,
respectively, 392 and 509. The General

Cases discussed

About this file

Document, cited by the archive. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 492 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.