Documents / Document

Black Vault compilation, pp. 91-93

The Black Vault · 134 pages · text from the file's own layer

This Black Vault compilation contains a September 1997 reply from the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense to John Greenewald's FOIA request, enclosing its UFO records. The enclosures include a Navy information sheet dismissing the Philadelphia Experiment and an Air Force UFO fact sheet listing 12,618 Project Blue Book sightings, 701 of them unidentified. They also include the National Academy of Sciences review endorsing the University of Colorado report and the concluding pages of a 1994 Air Force Roswell report attributing the wreckage to Project MOGUL.

  • p. 3 …The frequency of these queries predict- ably intensifies each time the experiment is mentioned by the…
  • p. 5 P ~ rsonnel a~ the Fourth Naval District believe that the ouestions -surrounding the so-called -Philadelphia…
  • p. 7 …Such timely review of the situation rv ~rjv~t~ g~~ups i~s~res t~at…
  • p. 11 …At the same time it is emphasized in the Report that (c) is an opinion based…
  • p. 18 …Some examples are the omission of the duration of the sighting, date, time, location, position in…
  • p. 19 …At other times, they appear to be saucer- Shaped and to have Ucbts mounted inside the…
  • p. 22 …the sun, planets, comets, meteorites, the universe, stars, constellations and planes; telescopes, the computation of time…
  • p. 24 …such timely review of the situation by private groups insures that sound evidence will not be…
  • p. 30 …According to The New York Times. ·unidentified !lying objeCts should be mvestigated further. a majority of…
  • p. 31 …The scans support the skeptical "Condon Comminee- conclusion that the photo could in fact be of…
  • p. 34 …At the time_of tne initial voice . report personnel at· 1-!a.lmstrom AFB and SAC…
  • p. 35 …of the incidents described above. They . had not received any information prior to this time. . • 6…
  • p. 36 …Such timely review or the situation by private groups insures that sound evidence will not be…
  • p. 42 …Give the date, hour and minute when the meteor appeared; also kind of time used. (4…
  • p. 63 …Give the date, hour and minute when the meteor appeared; also kind of time used. {4…
  • p. 72 …kt 290300 ~ST C~t 75, the ·..; r;iu ent:!. fied helico-:=ter ·.,;as siqhted ever…
  • p. 86 …PRCON showed several aircraft at the time, one near the l·:S}. (there was . no hovering…
  • p. 100 …Carter may have viewed the Planet Venus which, at certain times, may appear many times brighter…
  • p. 102 …AccorcMg :o The New York Times . ·unidentified flying ob jects should be •nvestigated further. a ma…
  • p. 105 …the Roswell Incident, this event has become the most celebrated UFO encounter of all time and…
  • p. 107 …collected at the Foster ranch site. UFO researchers, including those 2. New York Times. "Balloon Staggers…
  • p. 109 …Nevertheless, the attached report is a good faith effort and the fint time any agency of…
  • p. 111 …until the 1978-1980 time frame. Prior to that, the incident was dismissed because the AAF…
  • p. 113 …times, most research- ers will not dispute that anything in UFO history can compare with the…
  • p. 114 …the "Roswell Incident" was not considered one of these 1947 events until the 197Pr-1980 time…
  • p. 115 …weather balloons on the ranch, but _that what he found this time did not in any…
  • p. 116 …the persons interviewed were, in fact, stationed at, or lived near Roswell during the time in…
  • p. 117 …Collectively, the above represent the "pro" UFO writers who allege that the government is engaged in…
  • p. 120 …at Roswell Army Air Field during the period of time in question. It is anticipated that…
  • p. 121 …Since much of this testing done at nearby White Sands was secret at the time, it…
  • p. 122 …the 509th Bomb Group was the only military unit in the world at the time that…
  • p. 123 …U such a system had been in effect at the time, it would 21 l
  • p. 124 …Marcel, MD (son of the late Major Jesse Marcel; 11 years old at the time of…
  • p. 125 …Brazel; 14 years old at the time of the incident). Affidavit dated September 22, 1993. " ... The…
  • p. 126 …He thought at the time, and continued to do so today, that what he found was…
  • p. 128 …of the project, but they did not know of the project nickname at the time. They…
  • p. 129 …Additionally, a copy of a professional journal maintained at the time by A.P. Crary, provided…
  • p. 131 …first generation) prints of the photographs taken at the time by the Fort Worth Star-Telegram…
  • p. 132 …Although that project was Top Secret at the time, there was also no specific indication found…
  • p. 133 …faith but in the "fog of time," misinterpr.eted past events. The review of Air Force…
or man-made phenomena, twelve provided insufficient data for anal~is,
and seven were considered to be possible fabrications; none proved to
be "real objects with high strangeness." )
Teohni call y trained personne 1 were utili zed by the Uni. ve r s 1 t y.
The University gz'Oup included a sub-group on field investigation:s of
UFO reports; their narration and interpretations or cases are reasonable
and adequate. Leading gt'Cups were engaged uncler contract for specialized
work-- e.g., Stanford Research Institute on radar anomalies and a subsidiary
or the Raytheon Corporation for photograDIII.etric analyses. Divergent
Views or those rev scientists who have looked into · UFO:s were taken into
account. The history or the subject was also surveyed, including the
experiences in some other nations. Finally, extensive use was made
or many specialists in various public and private laboratories.
The Report makes clear that with the best means at our disposal, positive
correlation or all UFO reports with identifiable, known phenomena is
not possible. No study, past, current or future, can provide the basis
for stating categorically that a familiar phenomenon will necessarily
be linkable to every sighting. The Report 1! free or dogmatism
on this matter. It is also clear, as one goes through the
descriptions of UFO sightings, whether in the Report or in other literature,
that while some incidents have no positive identification with familiar
phenomena, they also have no positive identification with extraterrestrial
visitors or artifacts.
We think the methodology and approach were well chosen, in accordance
with accepted standards of scientific investigation.
UI. FINDINGS
The study concludes (a) that about 90 percent of all UFO reports
prove to be quite plausibly related to ordinary phenomena, (b) that
little if anything hu COlle fraa the stuey or UFOs in the past 21 years
that has added to scientific knowledge, and (c) that further extensive
study or· UFo sightings is not justified in the expectation that science
will be advanced thereby. At the same time it is emphasized in the
Report that (c) is an opinion based on evidence now available.
The Report's findings and evaluations -- essentially eight in number,
presented in its first section -- are concerned with official secrecy
on UFOs, UFOs as a possible defense hazard, the future governmental
han411ng or OFO-sighting reports, and five of them relate to the question
or wbat it any further investigation of O'FOs appear warranted in the
light or the study. We paraphrase and s•mnarize these findings and ·
evaluations be:ow, appending our comments.
1. On secrecy. Is the subject "shrouded in official secrecy"?
The study found no basis for this contention.
We accept this qnding or the stu.dy.
Attachment 2, pg 7

Cases discussed

About this file

Document, cited by the archive. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 134 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.